4 Thoughts On Maria Sharapova’s Appeal “Victory”

by Sean Randall | October 5th, 2016, 4:07 pm

After months and months, Maria Sharapova finally got the decision of her appeal. CAS cut her 2-year ban down to 15 months after determining Sharapova was at fault for not abiding by the rules but she didn’t do it on purpose.


1. Is Sharapova In The Clear?
That depends on who you ask. Her supporters, her fans will say she’s clear but her fellow players still have to wonder why she was taking that drug for 10 years with little disclosure and why she was taking more of it ahead of important matches. I wonder the same.

But CAS went out of their way to make it clear that she wasn’t taking it done for cheating. “Her plea of No Significant Fault or Negligence should be upheld,” they wrote.

So the debate will rage and I guess ultimately history will decide.

2. Who’s To Blame?
As I said before and as CAS stated, this falls directly on Sharapova. At the end of the day, she didn’t review the updated prohibited list and she paid dearly for it, losing 15 months of tennis and multi-millions in earnings and endorsements.

And to her credit, she admitted this was on her.

3. So Who Wins?
I don’t know if there are any winners in this ruling.

Maybe Angelique Kerber and some of the other players who benefited by not having to play Maria. But you could argue the bad PR from the Sharapova case only hurt the value of the WTA tour.

Sharapova is still hit with a 15-month ban and some will always consider her career suspect. She likely has made more enemies than friends over this. Is that a win? Hardly.

The ITF doping program had another case overturned (Cilic, Troicki have had similar results) and they again look like they don’t know what they are doing.

And the women’s tour still has to wait another 6.5 months before one of their top draws returns. So it remains a black eye on the sport.

4. What To Expect On Her Return?
The good news is her body will have had 15 months of pure rest, mental anguish aside.

The bad news is when she returns next May she’ll have just turned 30. Thirty in tennis is a tough number in tennis, and especially tough in women’s tennis where just nine different women have won a Slam after 30.

Thankfully (and luckily) for Sharapova, she might return at a time when Serena (now 35) continues to decline and the top of the women’s rankings remains in flux. So unless some new face takes over women’s tennis (Madison Keys? Angelique Kerber? Simona Halep? Karolina Pliskova?), which I doubt, she’ll be right in the mix by the time the US Open rolls around to start winning Slams again.

If healthy, the timing could turn out great for Maria.

You Might Like:
Verdict In Maria Sharapova’s Appeal Of Her 2-Year Ban To Be Announced 9am ET Tuesday
Roger Federer On Maria Sharapova’s Doping Ban: Zero Tolerance!
Maria Sharapova Files Appeal With CAS, Seeks Full Elimination Of 2-Year Doping Ban
Appeal Delayed! Maria Sharapova Won’t Be At The Olympics Or The US Open
Maria Sharapova’s 2018 Season Is Over

Don't miss any tennis action, stay connected with Tennis-X

Get the FREE TX daily newsletter

6 Comments for 4 Thoughts On Maria Sharapova’s Appeal “Victory”

chrisford1 Says:

My thoughts center on Serena 35, Sharapova 30 with no points -and the long show of those two nears curtain call. Which may mean a rejuvination of a sport too long presented to the non-avid tennis following public as all about those two female players.
Also, with Sharapova losing most of her sponsors, who had made her too big and important to demand she stop shrieking, it’s a good time for the WTA to finally crack down on it. And the woman shriekers that say they will keep on shrieking as long as Maria is never penalized for it

Roger Nadal Says:

Leave it to her to claim “victory” and blame all on the ITF. What about the hundreds of WTA players who somehow mysteriously did manage to get the memo this substance would be banned? How did those lowly ranked and poorly supported players know about this and other banned substances when they are not the highest paid female athlete on the planet? How did all of the other Russian athletes who also took this drug (no doubt also for “risk of developing diabetes”)prepare for the ban when it was a secret by the ITF? I hope every tennis fan turns his/her back on Maria, just as she has been known to do to her opponents, until she shows some semblance of humility.

elina Says:

Maria is FOS.

So is CAS.

ITF knows bans will generally be reduced based on history so have to set penalty high.

Should have stayed at two years,
To protect our poor ears.

Hope the new players take her out in early rounds to keep the shriek decibels to a minimum.

Willow Says:

Agree with RogerNadal and Elina, and it has nothing to do with been a woman, jealous of her looks etc, i mean YAWN give me a break purlease, i like the fighting qualities, never say die attitude etc dont get me wrong, i just dont care for her screaming like a banshee, when as Margot says she doesnt even do it in practice, turning her back on opponents whom all have to play at her pace ….

Willow Says:

Great write up Sean BTW ….

skeezer Says:

“this falls directly on Sharapova”

Top story: Tsitsipas Streaks To 10 Straight On Clay, Gets Rematch With Ruud In Barcelona Final